You've done it. You've braved the interviews, polished your CV, and finally, you have a fantastic new job offer on the table. But just as you're about to celebrate, your current employer swoops in with a counter-offer.  

More money, a new title, perhaps even promises of improved working conditions. It's flattering, it's tempting, and in the dynamic UK property sector – especially within estate agency and lettings – it's an increasingly common scenario.

​

So, should you stay or should you go? This isn't just about the immediate financial gain; it's about your long-term career trajectory, your professional reputation, and ultimately, your happiness.

The Rise of the Counter-Offer in UK Property

The UK property sector is highly competitive. Attracting and retaining top talent is a constant challenge for employers. With recruitment costs soaring and the time it takes to onboard a new employee, many firms are increasingly resorting to counter-offers as a seemingly quick fix.

Recruiters, like Worth Recruiting, witness this trend regularly. Employers want to avoid the disruption and expense of losing a good staff member, so they offer to match or even exceed the new offer.

However, as a job hunter, it's crucial to understand the implications beyond the immediate financial sweetener.

The Allure and the Illusion: Advantages of Accepting a Counter-Offer

On the surface, accepting a counter-offer can seem incredibly appealing:

• Comfort and Familiarity: You avoid the stress and effort of starting a new job, learning new systems, and building new relationships. You're already familiar with the team, the clients, and the company culture.

• Immediate Financial Gain: Often, the counter-offer will include a significant pay rise, addressing a key motivator for your job search.

• Validation of Your Worth: It can feel good to know your current employer values you enough to fight to keep you.

• Avoiding a Lengthy Notice Period Elsewhere: If your new role was with a competitor, accepting a counter-offer means you don't have to navigate a potentially awkward or lengthy notice period.

The Hidden Costs and the Reality: Disadvantages of Accepting a Counter-Offer

While the advantages are immediate, the disadvantages often play out over the longer term and can have significant repercussions:

1. The "Loyalty Question": Your employer now knows you were looking to leave. This can create a subtle, or sometimes not-so-subtle, shift in their perception of your loyalty. Will they still invest in your development as readily? Will you be considered for future promotions or key projects if they suspect you might leave again? This is a significant issue for career progression within the property sector.

2. Unaddressed Root Issues: Why were you looking for a new job in the first place? Was it genuinely just about the money? Often, deeper issues like lack of career progression, poor management, a toxic work environment, or dissatisfaction with the type of work contribute to the desire to move. A counter-offer rarely addresses these fundamental problems. The extra money might provide a temporary high, but the underlying frustrations are likely to resurface.

3. Short-Term Solution: Statistics from various recruitment agencies, including insights often shared by specialists like Worth Recruiting, reveal a stark reality: a significant percentage (often cited as 50-80%) of employees who accept counter-offers leave their company within 6-12 months. The initial "fix" wears off, and the original reasons for wanting to leave resurface.

4. Impact on Team Dynamics and Morale: News of your counter-offer and subsequent raise can spread, potentially causing resentment among colleagues who haven't received similar bumps in pay or opportunities. This can erode team morale and create internal pay disparities.

5. Burning Bridges with the New Employer (and Recruiters): Accepting a counter-offer means rejecting the offer from the new company. This can burn bridges and damage your professional reputation with that prospective employer. Furthermore, recruitment agencies like Worth Recruiting invest significant time and effort in finding you suitable roles. Backing out of an accepted offer can strain your relationship with them, potentially limiting their willingness to work with you in the future. In the tight-knit property sector, a strong relationship with a trusted recruiter is invaluable.

6. "Golden Handcuffs": If the counter-offer is a substantial pay rise, you might feel trapped. You're earning more, but if the original issues persist, you might find yourself stuck in a role you're unhappy with because a lateral move elsewhere would mean a pay cut.

What Should Job Hunters Be Aware Of?

• Be Clear on Your Motivations: Before you even start job hunting, understand why you want to leave. Is it truly just money, or are there deeper concerns? If it's the latter, a counter-offer is unlikely to be a long-term solution.

• Prepare for the Counter-Offer: Assume your current employer will make one. Think about how you will respond beforehand.

• Don't Use Offers as Leverage: Some job hunters deliberately seek offers to leverage a better deal from their current employer. This is a risky strategy that can backfire, damaging your reputation with both potential and current employers.

• Evaluate the Entire Package: Don't just look at the salary. Consider benefits, career progression, training opportunities, company culture, work-life balance, and management style for both the new offer and the counter-offer.

• Trust Your Gut (and Your Recruiter): If you've been working with a reputable agency like Worth Recruiting, they will have a deep understanding of the market, the companies, and your aspirations. They can offer invaluable, unbiased advice on the pros and cons of accepting a counter-offer in your specific situation within the property sector.

Should You Accept or Reject the Offer?

While every situation is unique, the general consensus among recruitment experts, including those at Worth Recruiting, is that it is rarely advisable to accept a counter-offer.

Managing Director of Worth Recruiting, Guy Hodge, advises, “The data overwhelmingly suggests that acceptance often leads to a short-term stay, followed by another job search within a year. The reasons you wanted to leave in the first place are seldom truly resolved by a pay rise.”

Instead, when considering a new offer, reflect on:

• Why you started looking: What were the core drivers?

• The new opportunity: Does it align with your career goals, values, and desired working environment?

• The potential for growth: Does the new role offer the development and progression you seek?

Chances of Remaining with an Employer Who Counter-Offers

As mentioned, the chances of an employee remaining with an employer who counter-offers in the long term are statistically low. The act of seeking external employment signifies a level of dissatisfaction that a last-minute financial incentive rarely truly remedies.

While some individuals do make it work, they are often the exception rather than the rule.

In the fast-paced and interconnected world of property, particularly within estate agency and lettings, making informed career decisions is paramount. While a counter-offer can be tempting, it's crucial to look beyond the immediate gain and consider the long-term impact on your career, your relationships, and your professional satisfaction.  

Working with a specialist recruiter can provide the guidance and perspective needed to navigate these complex situations and make the best choice for your future.

​

Looking for career advice in the property industry?

Talk to the experts!

Call Worth Recruiting on 01372 238300, visit our website www.worthrecruiting.me or send your CV to toptalet@worthrecruiting.me